Holster myths stick around in the firearm community because they often sound reasonable on the surface. A friend might repeat what they heard at the range, or someone online might share “tips” without much real-world testing. Over time, these ideas get repeated so often that people start to believe them as fact.
Myths also thrive because many new gun owners feel overwhelmed by all the choices. And instead of sorting through the noise, it’s easy to take shortcuts and stick with whatever sounds convincing.
That’s why it’s worth taking a closer look at common holster myths. Understanding what’s wrong with them can help you make safer, smarter choices and carry confidently every day.
Myth 1: “More retention is always better.”
Holster retention levels are often misunderstood.
A Level 1 retention holster secures your firearm using friction or a simple locking feature. Level 2 and Level 3 holsters add extra retention devices like hoods, levers, or straps. These higher holster retention levels are valuable in certain settings (like law enforcement or high-contact environments) where gun grabs are a real risk.
But more retention isn’t always better. Only choose higher retention if your situation requires it.
Otherwise, for everyday concealed carry, a Level 1 holster with solid trigger guard protection and reliable friction is usually the right balance of safety and accessibility.
For a deeper dive, read Your Definitive Guide to Holster Retention.
Myth 2: “A universal holster is just as good as a custom-fit holster.”
Universal or “one-size-fits-all” holsters sound convenient, but they often sacrifice safety. Poor fit can expose the trigger or allow the gun to shift inside the holster. That movement slows your draw and increases the risk of an accident.
On the other hand, custom-molded Kydex holsters are built for your specific firearm. They offer secure retention, faster access, and full trigger guard coverage, which makes them safer and more reliable.
Check out Why You Should Use a Custom Holster for EDC for more information.
Myth 3: “Carrying a gun will slow me down.”
The idea that carrying will always feel awkward usually comes from using the wrong setup. Features like adjustable ride height, forward or rearward cant, and durable but lightweight materials make all the difference. These details turn carrying from a burden into a habit you barely notice.
A properly designed holster should move with you, not against you. Modern designs are built to fit into daily life, whether it’s a belt holster for everyday carry, a chest rig for the backcountry, or a shoulder holster for long hours in a vehicle.
Myth 4: “Concealed carry is always uncomfortable.”
This is one of the most common holster myths, and it’s simply not true. Comfort depends on three main factors: your body type, where you carry, and the holster’s design.
A bulky holster with poor placement will dig into your side and make sitting miserable. But a well-designed holster spreads pressure, protects your skin from sharp edges, and sits at the right angle for your frame.
That’s why the most comfortable holster is the one matched to your needs. A comfortable concealed carry holster makes daily carry practical, not painful.
Myth 5: “Appendix carry is dangerous.”
Appendix carry gets a bad reputation because of fears about negligent discharges. The reality is that any position is unsafe with a poorly designed holster or careless handling.
For many, appendix carry offers faster access and better concealment. The key is using the right holster and practicing good habits.
A quality appendix holster provides complete trigger guard protection, solid retention, and easy reholstering. It’s no more dangerous than any other carry method when combined with safe handling practices.
Myth 6: “Holsters are only for concealed carry.”
Holsters aren’t just about concealed carry. Open carry, range practice, and backcountry adventures all require the right setup.
For example:
- Chest holsters are great for hiking, hunting, or fishing because they keep your firearm accessible while wearing a pack.
- Belt holsters remain the go-to for everyday carry, balancing concealment and speed.
- Shoulder holsters are ideal for long drives or situations where belt carry isn’t practical.
No matter the setting, a holster is about more than concealment. It’s about safety, accessibility, and carrying responsibly.
To learn more, read Chest Holster vs Shoulder Holster vs Hip Holster.
What Really Matters When Choosing the Right Holster
Here are the key factors to keep in mind.
Fit and Retention
For the best performance in a realistic scenario, the holster should fit your firearm exactly.
Ryan V. at GunfightersINC says, “A universal holster is not built for running or any genuine high-stress situation. A sloppy fit can expose the trigger, slow your draw, or allow unwanted movement that could be dangerous to yourself and everyone around you.”
At the same time, you want the right retention level for your situation. A simple friction-based holster works well for daily concealed carry, while a retention holster with added locking features makes more sense for duty use or high-contact environments.
The goal is balance: Secure enough to keep your firearm in place but not so restrictive that you can’t draw quickly when needed.
Comfort
If your holster isn’t comfortable, you’re less likely to carry consistently.
Comfort comes down to three things: material, position, and adjustability. Kydex provides rigid retention and durability, while leather offers a softer feel.
Placement (like appendix, hip, or chest) affects how natural it feels when you sit, walk, or bend. Adjustable ride height and cant allow you to fine-tune the holster so it works with your body instead of against it.
Purpose-Driven Choices
There’s no single “best holster.” The right choice depends on how and where you’ll use it.
For everyday carry, concealment and accessibility are priorities. For the outdoors, chest holsters shine because they keep your firearm clear of backpacks and gear. For duty use, higher retention and durability come first.
Matching the holster to your purpose is the simplest way to cut through misinformation and carry with confidence.
Read Gun Holsters for First-Time Gun Owners for more tips.
From Myths to Facts
Focus on what matters: fit, holster retention, comfort, and purpose. Carrying becomes second nature instead of a burden when you choose gear that balances speed with security and matches your lifestyle.
Don’t let outdated advice dictate how you carry. Invest in a holster designed for your firearm and your needs.
Explore GunfightersINC holsters to find trusted, custom-fit options built for safety, comfort, and everyday confidence.
September 15, 2025